Benz Ali: Sabah Sarawak nak Merdeka? Tak mustahil tapi bukan senang.

Comment by Benz Ali on the demands by Sabah and Sarawak to secede from Malaysia.

By Benz Ali · Bagi ceramah sikit kat adik² ni.. lebih baik bersikap pessimist dan realist dari so called optimist dan idealist.

Susah sebenarnya nak merdeka ni bro. Bukan senang. Bukanlah gw kata mustahil. Tapi bukan senang. Kau kena ada army kau sendiri. Polis kau sendiri. Senjata api kau sendiri. Mata wang kau sendiri. Sistem pendidikan kau sendiri. Segala²nya kau kena buat sendiri. Kau kena mula balik dari A atau dari zero. Bukan mustahil, tapi bukan kerja mudah.

Belum cerita siapa yang nak pimpin kau orang lagi. Pergaduhan atau perebutan puak² berbeza bagaimana? Lepas tu nak jadikan apa sebagai bahasa rasmi? Bahasa apa? Kau pilih satu bahasa etnik, etnik yang tak dipilih boleh terima tak? Orang2 yang khianat pada kau, kau nak apakan dia? Nak penjarakan? Kau kena buat penjara. Nak bagi banduan makan free je selama bertahun², kau kena kuat sistem ekonomi kau.

Sebelum tu, kat situ je kau perlu ada mahkamah kau sendiri. Nak ada mahkamah kena ada hakim, kena ada peguam. Nak ada semua tu, kau kena ada universiti kau sendiri. Nak ada universiti sendiri, kena ada ekonomi. Ekonomi kau macam mana masa tu? Kapitalis atau sosialis?

Negara mana, kau rasa akan sebelahi kau? Dan kau rasa kalau mereka sebelahi kau, mereka taknak apa²?

Jadi lepas dah terbebas dari "dijajah" Malaya, kau dijajah oleh siapa pula? Apa pula kena gadai masa tu. Cukup ke scholars kau nak memikirkan tentang segala² prospek, ancaman (SWOT) untuk negara baru kau ni?

Banyak kerja sebenarnya. Sembang kat FB bolehlah. Nak buat bukan senang. Banyak orang sekadar sembang saja (atau paling jauh pun macam kau ni la.. ) tapi hakikatnya, nak menubuhkan sebuah negara, bukan satu kerja mudah.

(Bahasa kau pakai pun Bahasa Melayu...menunjukkan "keterjajahan" kau pada Melayu sangat kuat... dan pastikah kau, di kala kau menolak Bahasa Kebangsaan ini, dan menanggalkan Malaysia ini, keadaan akan lebih baik?)

Nation state ni, suka tak suka, harus suka sajalah...melainkan ada Perang Dunia Ke-3 yang akan meranapkan semua sistem yang ada pada hari ini, maka takyahlah buat kerja sia² dan perabis masa orang lain. (Banyak orang dihabiskan masanya secara sia² oleh masalah orang lain, seperti masalah Anwar Ibrahim, kau nak buat macamtu gak ke?)

Kita ada kat dunia ni sekejap je. Elok fikir ubah dari dalam tanpa merosakkan orang awam. Fikir orang lain sama berbanding diri sendiri. Kalau orang lain taknak, macam mana nak cakap kita ni mewakili mereka?

Kau tak rasa ke, benda ni kalau dah boleh buat, mesti hari tu lagi (1963 atau paling lewat pun sebelum 2000) orang dah buat pun.

-aku tulis panjang² response ni sebab aku layan gak idea² macam ni.. tapi kita kenalah jugak kritik sesuatu idea itu supaya kita tak jadi idealis yang hidup dalam angan²-

Translation:

Give a lecture to these kids.. It's better to be pessimist and realistic than the so called optimist and idealist.

It's actually hard to be independent bro. Not happy. It's not me who said impossible. But not happy. You have to have your own army. Police you yourself. Your own gun. Your own currency. Your own education system. You have to do everything by yourself. You have to start back from A or from zero. Not impossible, but not easy work. Haven't told yet who wants to lead you people. How is the fight or clash of clans different? After that, what do you want to make as the official language? What language is it? You choose one ethnic language, can you accept the ethnicity that is not chosen? The people who betrayed you, what do you want to do with them? Want to go to jail? You need to go to jail. If you want to give prisoners free food for years, you have to strengthen your economic system. Before that, that's where you need your own court. If you want a court, you need a judge, you need a lawyer. If you want to have all that, you need to have your own university. If you want your own university, you need to have an economy. How was your economy back then? Capitalist or socialist ? Which country do you think will be next to you? And you think if they are next to you, they don't want anything? So after you are freed from "colonization" Malaya, who colonized you? What if got pawned at that time. Is it enough for your scholars to think about all the prospects, threats (SWOT) for your new country? A lot of work actually. Chat on FB is allowed. It's not easy to do. Many people are just chatting (or even the furthest like you.. ) but the truth is, to establish a country, is not an easy task.

(The language you use is Malay... showing your "civilization" to Malays is very strong... And are you sure, when you reject this National Language, and remove this Malaysia, things will be better? )

Nation state ni, like it or not, just have to like it ... Unless there is a 3rd World War that will collapse all the systems that exist today, then no need to do useless work and waste other people's time. (Many people waste their time in vain by other people's problems, like Anwar Ibrahim's problem, do you want to do that? ) We are only in this world for a short time. It's good to think about changing from the inside without damaging the public. Think others are the same compared to your self. If others don't want it, how can we say we represent them? Don't you think, if this thing can be done, it must be that day (1963 or at the latest before 2000) people would have done it.

-I write this response in length because I don't entertain ideas like this.. but we also have to criticize an idea so that we will not be idealists who live in fantasy2-